Tempo logotype
6 min read

How to use analogous estimating effectively in project management

From Team '23

Tempo Team

One of a project manager’s primary roles is financial management — accurately forecasting how much a job will cost and how long it will take to complete. That’s no mean feat, especially at the initial stages of a project when details are still in flux and data is limited.

Thankfully, a simple technique known as analogous estimating can help establish budgets and timelines based on data from previous projects. Whether you need a complete financial forecast or a task-by-task estimate, this methodology will provide projections you can feel confident including in the project plan.

What’s analogous estimating?

The Project Management Institute’s (PMI) Project Management Book of Knowledge (PMBoK) defines analogous estimating as:

“...an estimation method based on information from historical data from previous projects for similar tasks or deliverables.”

Comparing variables from similar projects allows project management to work with limited data to estimate outcomes and plan work accordingly. These variables can include:

Analogous estimating in project management is a top-down estimation method, meaning leadership initially establishes the job’s total cost or duration and then divides that value according to the work breakdown structure (WBS). Managers use this technique to create estimates for the entire initiative or individual tasks that make up the project.

The 4 analogous estimation categories

Every analogous estimation falls into one of four primary categories:

  1. Absolute-value or single-point estimate: This estimate provides an absolute value for cost or duration based on similarities between current and past projects.

  2. Ratio estimate: For this estimate, you apply a modifying factor to historical data to improve accuracy. So if costs have increased by 5% since completing a previous initiative, the project manager would calculate the current estimate and apply that variable to the data.

  3. Range estimate: Primarily used in adaptive or agile project management, range estimates evaluate parameters from multiple similar projects to determine the potential cost and duration distributions.

  4. Three-point estimate: The three-point method generates three forecasts — an optimistic, pessimistic, and most likely projection. The project manager then finalizes the estimate using triangular or PERT distribution analysis

    .

Applying analogous estimating: 5 circumstances

While there are several circumstances where analogous estimation is the go-to forecasting method, we wanted to highlight the following five most common conditions.

1. Project initiation

Analogous estimating places a preliminary value on the project and its elements to determine whether it’s viable and worth pursuing. As you uncover insights and projections during project planning, you can revisit initial estimates to refine the forecast.

2. Limited data

If you’re working from little-to-no historical data, it can be difficult to anticipate a project’s potential for success. Analogous estimating lets leadership create a forecast to determine whether it’s worth proceeding.

3. Vague parameters

When bidding on a project, you may find that the RFP contains few details or no access to useful project information. The estimator can apply the analogous methodology to generate rough budget and duration forecasts.

4. Past experience

An experienced project manager has a bounty of prior knowledge to draw from. They can use their learnings from previous initiatives to establish an analogous estimate by comparing past and present project requirements.

5. Minimal requirements

At times, an organization bids on a project that only requires a basic idea of cost and duration. Analogous estimation is the least labor-intensive method to obtain the information stakeholders need.

Analogous estimating pros and cons

It’s essential to understand the pros and cons of this estimation method to ensure realistic expectations regarding accuracy. You must also prepare contingencies to address shortfalls between estimates and actual results.

Pros

  • Estimating produces highly accurate forecasts when using comparable projects

  • Stakeholders obtain valid cost estimates during project initiation

  • You can calculate trade-offs between time and cost

  • It’s easy to weigh individual task effort and duration

Cons

  • Data from historical projects may not be comparable

  • A lack of information could lead to incorrect forecasts

  • Estimators commonly overlook low-level components like smaller tasks assigned to particular departments or individuals

  • The estimate may fail to account for the complete list of resources or inflation, leading to inaccurate cost predictions

  • Risks or issues may be unaccounted for, resulting in additional expenditures and cost overruns

Analogous versus parametric estimating

The other option to forecast project budgeting and timeline is parametric estimating. This method uses a mathematical formula and historical and statistical data from industry sources to accurately calculate the time, costs, and resources a project needs for completion.

Here’s the algorithm:

E_parametric = A_old / P_old X P_curr

where,

E_parametric = parametric estimate

A_old = historical cost or time value

P_old = historical parameter value

P_curr = current value of the project parameter

Both analogous and parametric estimation techniques are valuable and valid in project management. But because parametric estimating considers differences between new and old projects and uses unit-wise calculations for cost, duration, and other variables, the statistical model delivers greater accuracy to its forecasts.

How to use analogous estimation: 6 steps

If you’ve concluded that analogous estimation is the best course for your project, a systemic approach to generating your predictions is critical to ensure accurate forecasts. Here’s the step-by-step process to apply the model.

1. Identify the project’s domain and resources required

Determine which discipline your project will involve. Knowing whether you’re working on a marketing initiative or product development will help source information on technology, materials, and staffing requirements. Once you understand the domain, search the company archives for comparable projects to ground your estimations.

2. Locate similar endeavors

List 15–20 past projects similar to yours based on variables like project scope, context, and team structure. Then, narrow the list down to one or two comparable projects to work from. Remember: The stronger the comparisons, the more accurate final estimation will be.

3. Compare current and historical projects

After identifying your comps, compare projects based on strongly similar variables. Review project boards for information about timelines, team size, and budget. This information will inform estimations for your current initiative.

4. Formulate estimates

Generally, project managers generate rough analogous cost estimates and timeline projections at this phase. Make a rough estimate for both these parameters based on projected tasks and stakeholder requirements.

5. Review historical tasks and activities

Search for similar activities in previous and current projects to find comparable elements. These commonalities will help generate reliable cost and duration estimates for individual requirements.

6. Consolidate information to finalize estimates

Decide whether you want to present stakeholders with a single value, range, or three-point estimate, then calculate your projections. Once you’ve established the values, use the WBS to visualize project execution. From there, you can define priorities and assign tasks and deadlines to team members, keeping everyone on track.

If you can’t locate projects similar to yours, don’t worry — you can break down the work into tasks and research to find similar elements across archived projects. The process is a little more extensive and relies on your judgment to define similarities, but it’s still viable.

Bringing it all together with Tempo

Take some guesswork out of project estimations using Timesheets, Tempo’s time, cost, and resource management tool. The Timesheet platform helps project managers visualize their work’s size, scope, and resource commitments to generate accurate forecasts for all stakeholders.

Once the transition from project planning to execution is complete, leverage Jira-enabled Strategic Roadmaps to create audience-friendly roadmaps that keep your team on track. Roadmaps include budget milestones and task deadlines to help you prioritize tasks, build alignment, and ensure deliverables arrive on time.

Tags

  • Strategic Roadmaps

Strategic Roadmaps

Strategic roadmapping

Build your portfolio vision with Strategic Roadmaps. With powerful visualization capabilities, you can communicate strategy to the entire organization and gain alignment around strategic objectives, product goals, and milestones.

Start a Free Trial
Special Offer

Explore More Content

Get the data you need to succeed

Time Tracker

Extend your Jira with prebuilt and highly configurable reports for straightforward time tracking.

Learn more

Strategic portfolio management for PMO leaders

Strategic portfolio management for PMO leaders

Tempo gives PMO directors and portfolio managers the tools to reduce delivery friction, align teams, and drive measurable outcomes.

Learn more

No-code Power BI ServiceNow integration

Power BI Connector for ServiceNow

Seamlessly connect ServiceNow with Power BI, transforming complex enterprise data into actionable insights and driving smarter, data-informed decisions across the organization

Learn more

Align your organization with proactive portfolio management

Portfolio Manager (LiquidPlanner)

Predictive scheduling and the ability to forecast project timelines and spot risks so you can meet deadlines with confidence.

Learn more

Roadmapping software for teams of all sizes

Strategic Roadmaps (Roadmunk)

The roadmapping tool designed for high-performing teams delivering boardroom-ready strategic roadmaps.

Learn more

No more reporting limitations

Custom Charts for Confluence

Create and share all kinds of highly visual and customizable charts directly on your Confluence pages.

Learn more
Colleagues interacting around a desk

No-Code Power BI Jira Integration

Power BI Connector for Jira

Effortlessly bridge Jira with your preferred BI tool, unlocking unparalleled insights and enhancing decision-making

Learn more

No-code BigQuery Jira integration

BigQuery Connector for Jira

Integrate Jira with Google BigQuery to seamlessly export and sync data for advanced analytics and customized reporting

Learn more

Jira ITSM Solutions with Tempo

ITSM

Build and scale a custom ITSM solution at your own pace with Tempo's modular suite of integrated tools. Enhance Jira's capabilities and take control of your entire IT portfolio.

Learn more

Real-time collaboration and capacity planning in Jira

Capacity Planner

A powerful team resource management tool designed to optimize capacity planning and project management in Jira

Learn more
Team working together at board with sticky notes

No-code Power BI monday.com integration

Power BI Connector for monday.com

Get powerful data export capabilities and connect monday.com to Power BI effortlessly

Learn more

Jira Project Cost Tracking

Financial Manager

Project financial management for Jira & Timesheets. Monitor project costs, expenses, revenue, billing & budgets. Track Capex/Opex

Go to marketplace

Time Tracking Software for Jira

Timesheets

Tempo’s intuitive automation and Jira-native design make it the most trusted time tracking tool for enterprise organization.

Learn more

Unified time and team management

Timesheets and Capacity Planner

Seamlessly manage project timelines and resources while accurately tracking time spent on tasks. This integration enhances visibility, improves planning accuracy, and supports data-driven decision-making for better overall project outcomes.

Learn more

Ensure compliance and optimize spending

Governance and auditing

Portfolio governance and auditing excellence

Learn more

Align strategy and execution

Structure PPM and Strategic Roadmaps

For planning leaders looking to add a big-picture roadmap view to their structured Jira data, this integration is essential. Improve visibility to leadership, reduce reporting admin, and keep your team aligned.

Learn more

No-code Tableau Jira integration

Tableau Connector for Jira

Effortlessly bridge Jira with Tableau, unlocking unparalleled insights and enhancing decision-making

Learn more

Industry-leading project plan and roadmap visualizations with a Gantt chart extension

Gantt Charts for Structure PPM

Visualize project plans and roadmaps with a Gantt chart extension for Jira

Learn more

Jira Portfolio Management PPM

Structure by Tempo

Jira Project Portfolio Management (PPM): Visualize data and manage projects within spreadsheet-like tables — in less than a minute

Go to marketplace

Jira Team & Resource Management

Capacity Planner

#1 Jira Resource Management App: Optimize team allocation, skillset utilization, capacity planning & project management

Go to marketplace

Take control of your projects

Portfolio Manager and Jira

Portfolio Manager integrates seamlessly with Jira to give you predictive scheduling, real-time scenario modeling, and advanced resource management – ensuring you stay on track, no matter what challenges arise.

Learn more

Jira Time Tracking

Timesheets by Tempo

#1 Jira Time Tracking & AI Apps: Log Tempo Timesheets for Planning, Project Management & Billing. Plugin Office365, Google & Slack

Go to marketplace

Unified time and team management

Timesheets and Structure

Combining Tempo Timesheets and Structure PPM provides a unified view of time tracking and project progress, enabling more accurate reporting and effective portfolio management. Simplify workflows, enhance collaboration, and ensure projects stay on time and within budget.

Learn more

Centralize real-time plans in one view

Structure and Gantt Charts

Gain a more complete project management solution, simplifying project reporting, improving collaboration, and ensuring projects stay on time and within budget.

Learn more

Custom charts and dashboards for Jira

Custom Charts for Jira

See how work is progressing and where blockers are with the most flexible reporting app in Jira.

Learn more

Powered by Structure’s custom hierarchies, visualize your roadmap, project plans, timeline & dependencies within Jira Gantt charts

Go to marketplace

Agile at Scale Software

Agile at Scale

Adapt to changing business needs, rapidly adjust plans, and reallocate investment.

Learn more

Never lose track of a brilliant idea again

Idea Manager for Strategic Roadmaps

Never lose a brilliant idea again. Idea Manager for Strategic Roadmaps has built-in best practices to help.

Learn more

Monitor financial health at every level

Financial Manager

Monitor projects and portfolios to get simple, clear, and real-time views of your costs, budgets, and profits that can be shared throughout your entire organization.

Learn more

Project and program management for Jira

Structure PPM

Visualize all your Jira data & manage portfolios of projects in real-time.

Learn more

Strategic Portfolio Management

Strategic Portfolio Management

Modern modular PPM solutions that scale with your business. Align your teams with the integrated platform that bridges the gap between strategy and execution.

Learn more